Calcalist: At a Beijing Accelerator, Israeli Startups Adapt to China
“We thought we knew our global competitors, but when I came to China I discovered a local company with a similar product I did not know existed,” said Omer Shubi, head of China business at muscle meter for cyclists startup Watteam Ltd., in a recent interview with Calcalist. “If you google the company you will not see results, but its products are sold on (Chinese online retailer) Taobao, and in Chinese you will find hundreds of links.”
Watteam is one of five companies currently participating in an accelerator program for Israeli startups in Beijing. The six-month program was announced in November 2017 by the Israeli Ministry of Economy, in collaboration with Chinese coworking firm DayDayUp and ShengJing360, the global investment division of consulting and venture capital firm ShengJing Group. The program, which started in March, offers mentorship and advice on legal and regulatory issues related to the Chinese market.
Boosted by governmental efforts on both sides, economic ties between China and the Israeli tech ecosystem have been strengthening in recent years. Names like Tencent and Baidu, once obscure references to almost all Israelis, are now familiar names in the local tech. Several Chinese-linked accelerators are also looking to tap Israeli innovation, including government-backed Chengdu-Israel Incubator, which launched an Israeli offshoot in November, and the city of Beijing, which in April announced the launch of an economic mission in Tel Aviv, to be run by the ShengJing Group.
Hundreds of Chinese delegations come to Israel yearly, leading to an increased participation of Chinese companies in Israel-based venture funds, and to direct investment deals in Israeli startups. In May, Alibaba founder and Chairman Jack Ma visited Israel at the head of a large delegation, meeting with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, and local venture capital firms and tech entrepreneurs. In October 2017, the e-commerce giant announced plans to set up offices in Tel Aviv as part of a $15 billion global research and development push.
Alibaba is also invested in several Israeli companies, and in the last quarter of 2017 it acquired the assets of Israel-based QR codes startup Visualead Ltd. The largest Chinese acquisition of an Israel-based or Israel-linked company to date is the $4.4 billion acquisition of social gaming company Playtika, then owned by Caesar’s Interactive, by a Chinese conglomerate in 2016.
More and more Israeli companies are looking to break into the Chinese market, opening local branches and inking local partnerships. Often, however, they run into difficulties due to language, legal and cultural barriers.
From an outsider’s point of view, it is often hard to understand nuances, explained Mr. Shubi, who arrived in Beijing in March. He recounted a marketing initiative he undertook, gifting Watteam-branded hats in greenish-turquoise to the employees of a Chinese partner. Immediately, he was told no one would wear them. In China, the expression “wearing a green hat” (戴绿帽子) means cuckold.
Through the accelerator program, Watteam has already signed a first partnership with Blackbird, a Chinese company developing bicycle-related technology. But the business culture involved in the deal was very different from what startups working in the U.S. or Europe face.
In his previous experiences, most of the negotiations centered around contract details, with both sides going over the fine print regarding the amount and timing of the payments, Mr. Shubi said. “Face to face meetings are less important, and in Australia we closed a large client without even meeting.” In China, however, he met with the CEO of Blackbird seven times before a contract was signed.
“You have to be present physically in China, because if you rely just on email communication you’ll stop receiving replies at some point,” Mr. Shubi concluded. It is also harder to realize if partners are unsatisfied with something, he explained, so personal connections make a big difference when it comes to understanding and solving difficulties
Guanxi, the building of mutually beneficial relationships, is an important concept in Chinese culture. People in In China will invest in companies based on trust, because they are not necessarily familiar with the company’s financials, explained Helena Javitte, director of the innovation program at DayDayUp, who provides support to the startups participating in the accelerator program.
Israelis are very direct, and they are “pushers,” Ms. Javitte said, they want everything to happen fast but building relationships takes time. Israelis like to flaunt technology, but most Chinese companies will prefer working with a local partner over an international one, making humility a needed requirement, she added.
Israeli companies looking to operate in China run into a multitude of difficulties, said Ofir Gur, the Israel Embassy's economic attaché in China. It can be something as simple as opening a local bank account, acquiring a phone line or being granted a visa, he said, “and without overcoming those issues you cannot even begin to discuss business development.”
“The Chinese market is already very difficult, and a company not fully committed is just throwing money away. A critical success factor, in my opinion, is to relocate someone from senior management to China,” Mr. Gur said.